Vitalik left the X app but not X, and lost interest in the daily fight

He kept posting through a multi-platform client that merges X, Bluesky, Farcaster and Lens, and says the main benefit is the missing algorithm.

In brief

Vitalik Buterin's 'digital minimalism' essay argues that physical minimalism is no longer the hard part. The goal is to make each use of technology a deliberate choice.

A reader with a detailed view on ad incentives, and another who dropped his phone plan eight years ago, answered with very different versions of the same idea.

Quitting the interface, not the platform

In his essay, Vitalik Buterin argues that physical minimalism is worthwhile but no longer the main challenge; digital minimalism means making each use of technology a deliberate choice rather than a default habit. His experiment was to leave the X interface but not the platform. He did most of his posting through Firefly, a client that shows X, Bluesky, Farcaster and Lens in one feed and cross-posts to all four, which he says he has done for much of 2025.

His diagnosis is blunt. X is engaging but neither informative nor pleasant, and toxicity peaked around late 2024 and early 2025. He describes a loop: tap an extreme post out of morbid curiosity, tell the recommender you're interested, get more of it. He suspects his setup's main benefit is the absence of the algorithmic feed. Back on X, he found he barely cared about the day's culture-war debate.

The business-model objection

"Twitter gets money from ads. They can sell more ads for more money when they can demonstrate eyeballs and eyeball time. Therefore, they're incentivized to keep your eyeballs on the app for as long as possible. If that means putting car accidents in front of you, that's what it'll do!" — a commenter based in Taipei

He does not buy the essay's suggestion that algorithm improvements calmed the feed, and says he tried Mastodon and Bluesky, where he found little real conversation.

Going all the way

One commenter described a decade of deletion: airplane mode first, then apps, until his phone was boring enough to cancel the cell subscription eight years ago. He has carried no phone since, pays in cash, and says he has "never been happier or more productive."

Another is closer to the essay's spirit. A former heavy Twitter user deleted the account cold turkey when it changed owners, and for Instagram uses iPhone Screen Time limited to 20 minutes a day, with the passcode set by someone else.

Minimalism as a luxury

"minimalism, privacy, security, these are all mostly a pursuit of luxury." — a commenter who has written about the topic

He argues that tech rarely produces a truly distinguishing luxury good, and lists the ones that did, from the iPhone to early Facebook and blue-check Twitter.

Get breakdowns like this every day

The top Hacker News stories, unpacked — by email, Telegram, or RSS.

Next story · 7 of 11 Read more
🚀Tech

Volta infostealer asks Claude to price its victims before the attackers touch them

Cisco Talos found a Windows stealer that sends each victim's stolen identity report to an LLM and gets back a section titled 'WHAT THEY'RE WORTH'.

★ 233 · 💬 128 · blog.talosintelligence.com · 2 min