His instructions scream 'DO NOT PARSE ANYTHING MANUALLY.' Claude tries anyway (replicated.live)
The post's thesis: LLMs are "brilliant but clumsy," so wrap that non-determinism in formal tooling. Ragel spits out a 10,000-line correct parser instantly; Claude, told in all caps never to parse by hand, does it anyway, and once committed a build/ directory twice.
The sharpest reply says he misnamed the problem: an LLM's trouble was never determinism. Its input is natural language, which was never formally defined, "words have meaning," and no parser generator can replace the layer that guesses what you meant.
Sign in to save